The Best Ice Cream Makers in 2019

Product Expert supports our readers with thousands of hours of research and reporting to help you find the products for your life and your family. You support us through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn more about what we do.

The majority of people love ice cream and now that you can create your own, what better way to end a meal, satisfy a craving for something sweet or to cool off on a hot summer’s day. You can create a huge number of flavor combinations and if you are the type of person who wants to watch the calories, then you can even use your ice cream maker to make variations of ice cream like dairy or sugar-free ice cream, sorbet or even frozen yogurt.

Create new and already loved recipes for your family to remember for years to come with our list of top ten best ice cream makers and you’ll wonder how you’ve ever coped without one.

best overall rating
  • Make ice cream in 20mins
  • Gelato, frozen yogurt or sorbet, too
  • Effective paddle speeds up creation
premium choice rating
  • Make ice cream in 60mins
  • Suitable for ice cream or gelato
  • Two different paddles
great value rating
  • 4 quarts in 40 minutes
  • Makes many different things
  • Automatic switch off

Take a look at this list of our favorite ice cream makers and decide which one would be the best one for you and your family.

View the Best Ice Cream Maker, Below.

best overall rating

1. Cuisinart ICE-70

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

To make two quarts of ice cream or alternatively gelato, frozen yogurt or sorbet, then take a look at using this ice cream maker. It has an effective paddle within which decreases the wait you have for your ice cream. Use the easy to read LCD screen to control your ice cream maker, change the settings and set the timer.

This intelligent machine will turn itself off automatically if you are otherwise engaged when the ice cream maker process has been completed. Add your ingredients into the ice cream maker in a mess and danger-free way by introducing them through the spout and be sure to use the included measuring cup so that you can get precise quantities and delicious results.

Why We Like It
  • Make ice cream in 20mins
  • Gelato, frozen yogurt or sorbet, too
  • Effective paddle speeds up creation
  • LCD screen, spout, measurer
  • Automatic switch off
Capacity
2 quarts
Freezing Time
20 mins
Dimensions
9.7 x 8.6 x 13.2 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Cuisinart ICE-70 ice cream maker because of the speed and preciseness at which it creates delicious frozen treats.

Editor Rating
premium choice rating

2. Cuisinart ICE-100

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Count down for sixty minutes with the visible timer on this ice cream maker so that you know exactly when your next batch of ice cream is ready for taste testing. This Cuisinart ICE-100 has the same type of compressor as a commercial style machine which means that it has good technique and is able to replicate a traditional tasting ice cream for you within the comfort of your own kitchen.

Choose between two styles of paddles so that you can make gelato or super creamy ice cream. Use the blue LCD screen to set your ice cream maker appropriately and rest assured that you have ten minutes where your ice cream maker will automatically keep your ice cream or gelato perfectly cool.

Why We Like It
  • Make ice cream in 60mins
  • Suitable for ice cream or gelato
  • Two different paddles
  • Blue LCD screen
  • 10 mins cool time
Capacity
1.5 quarts
Freezing Time
60 mins
Dimensions
16.7 x 12 x 9.3 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Cuisinart ICE-100 because it automatically counts down the length of time you have remaining until your ice cream or gelato is ready for eating.

Editor Rating
great value rating

3. Hamilton Beach 68330N

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

This quick acting, large capacity ice cream maker is ideal for bigger families or parties. It can easily create up to 4 quarts of ice cream in a maximum of 40 minutes. You can create a wide array of cold treats using this ice cream maker including gelato, sherbet, custard and frozen yogurt with very little effort. Simply add the ingredients you need and this clever ice cream maker starts work.

It will stop churning when your dessert of choice is ready, completely automatic in doing so. Prevent spills or accidents by using the easy-lock lid and wash really simply by hand. If you’re stuck for ideas or want new desserts to create, take a look in the free recipe guide that comes with this innovative ice cream maker.

Why We Like It
  • 4 quarts in 40 minutes
  • Makes many different things
  • Automatic switch off
  • Easy-lock lid, hand washable
  • Free recipe book included
Capacity
4 quarts
Freezing Time
20 – 40 mins
Dimensions
15.3 x 12.5 x 11.1 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Hamilton Beach 68330N because there are so many different desserts options you’ll never be stuck for something to serve up to your family or friends.

Editor Rating

4. Cuisinart ICE-30R

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Smart in aesthetic and smart in its uses, this ice cream maker can make two quarts of ice cream in just 25 minutes. Its eye-catching design is of red and brushed metal and is incredibly simple to use. Create sorbet and frozen yogurt with this clever, compact ice cream maker. With its heavy-duty motor, you can also create cold drinks of your choice as well.

If you want to mix in more ingredients as your ice cream maker is working, simply use the spout so that your ice cream maker does not have to be disturbed from its churning process. This automated ice cream maker has a double-insulated freezer bowl to conserve the freezing process and automated paddle – it’s simple!

Why We Like It
  • Makes 2 quarts of ice cream
  • Completes churning in 25 minutes
  • Ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt
  • Ingredient spout, automated paddle
  • Double insulated freezer bowl
Capacity
2 quarts
Freezing Time
25 mins
Dimensions
10.5 x 10.88 x 16 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Cuisinart ICE-30R ice cream maker because it is double insulated so keeps your ice cream frozen for longer and is fast in its production.

Editor Rating

5. Nostalgia ICMP400WD

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

If you are of the opinion that the traditional approach makes the best ice cream, then you will love this ice cream maker. Replicating the old fashioned milk churns, you can make many different flavors of ice cream using the specific kits provided for this machine, use the recipes provided, or create your own flavors. Make 4 quarts in a maximum of 30 minutes ensuring everyone’s satisfied.

This is an easy to use, easy to clean ice cream maker requiring absolutely no manual labor from you, and has a transparent lid so that you can store any remaining ice cream and motor lock to ensure that all parts of the ice cream maker are kept in place.

Why We Like It
  • Traditional look and churn
  • Use kits or recipes
  • Makes 4 quarts in 30mins
  • Easy use/clean
  • Storage lid, motor lock
Capacity
4 quarts
Freezing Time
20 – 30 mins
Dimensions
12.25 x 12.25 x 15.75 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Nostalgia ICMP400WD because it promotes the traditional approach to ice cream making in our modern world and does so in such a delicious way.

Editor Rating

6. Whynter ICM-200LS

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Use this ice cream maker to create two liters of ice cream without having to use any manpower yourself. This is a stainless steel machine working at 180 watts and is very easy to use. Remove the bowl so that you can serve from it directly, and the churning blade is perfect for consistent movement of the churning ice cream.

No need to stand around waiting for your ice cream maker to finish its job – this machine has an audible timer so you can hear it even in another room of the house and is clever enough to automatically shut down its own motor to protect itself when the ice cream is completely solid so as to avoid damage to parts.

Why We Like It
  • Stainless steel, 180 watts
  • Removable bowl and blade
  • Easy store/clean
  • Audible timer
  • Automatic shutdown motor protection
Capacity
2.1 quarts
Freezing Time
30 – 60mins
Dimensions
16.75 x 11.25 x 10.25 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Whynter ICM-200LS because it has a timer you can hear from other parts of your home and will protect itself from damage by automatically switching off its motor.

Editor Rating

7. Nostalgia ICMP600WD

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

When quantity and quality are a necessity in your home, this Nostalgia ice cream maker is worth looking at. Creating an impressive 6 liters of ice cream in a maximum of 30 minutes, you will never be short for a sweet treat. With its real wood exterior, powerful motor and recipe book, there really isn’t much that you need to do!

You can choose to use a Nostalgia kit or create your own flavors, use the transparent lid to store any leftovers and use the motor locks to make sure that your ice cream maker parts are all kept in place.

Why We Like It
  • Makes 6 quarts in 30mins
  • Wood exterior, powerful motor
  • Included recipes
  • Transparent lid
  • Motor lock secures machine
Capacity
6 quarts
Freezing Time
20 – 30 mins
Dimensions
13 x 13 x 19.8 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Nostalgia ICMP600WD because it makes a large volume of ice cream in such a short space of time, with the ice cream tasting the traditional way but with very little effort required from the user.

Editor Rating

8. Cuisinart ICE-45

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Replicate the Mr. Whippy style ice cream from your own kitchen with this soft serve ice cream maker. It makes 1.5 quarts of ice cream in as quick as 20 minutes and can add mix-ins into the ice cream as it is dispensed. Choose your desired number of mix-ins whenever you go for ice cream, just pulling down the dispensary handle to start the ice cream maker off to give you the ice cream you are craving.

It even has its own cone holder so the kids can help themselves without requiring bowls. A healthier option for families as this ice cream maker does not require salt, ice or chemicals in order to create delicious ice cream at an impressive speed.

Why We Like It
  • Makes 1.5 quarts in 20mins
  • Double insulated freezer bowl
  • Chemicals, salt, ice-free
  • Easy use/clean
  • Great for kids
Capacity
1.5 quarts
Freezing Time
20 mins
Dimensions
9.86 x 7.75 x 17.25 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Cuisinart ICE-45 because it’s so family friendly. This ice cream maker doesn’t use chemicals or salt and kids can help themselves simply by pulling the lever, choosing cone, bowl, and toppings along the way.

Editor Rating

9. Breville BCI600XL

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

The aesthetically pleasing Breville ice cream maker is smart in looks and its approach. With its LCD display panel, you can alter the settings and remain in control, an indicator bar so that you can monitor the progress of the ice cream maker, and an indicator which tells you when to add any ingredients you may want as extras. It makes you aware when you need to press the start button, and there are separate indicators for pre-cooling options and for safe blade removal.

Select the style of ice cream you want, the degree of frozenness and you can also ask the machine to keep your ice cream cool even when churning has been completed.

Why We Like It
  • Silver, sleek, smart, safe
  • LCD display
  • Multiple indicators
  • Select frozenness
  • Keep ice cream cool
Capacity
1.5 quarts
Freezing Time
30 – 60mins
Dimensions
15.8 x 11 x 11 Inches
Our Verdict

We like the Breville BCI600XL because it is such a clever machine and is very safety compliant too. It indicates when it requires attention when it’s safe to remove the blade and when it’s time to supply additional ingredients to your recipe.

Editor Rating

10. iSiLER Maker

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

This ice cream maker is so simple and safe to use that children can use it. It creates 1.5 quarts of ice cream which makes about 12 balls and will feed five to six people. It has an impressive mixing paddle so that the soft serve ice cream is fluffy and smooth, an ingredient chute so that little extras can be added without fingers getting caught up in the paddle, and the bowl has double insulated walls.

This bowl needs to be frozen before it is used for 24 hours so that the cooling solution is at the appropriate temperature. Use the LCD screen to set it, rely on the automatic shut down and know that it is really easy to clean.

Why We Like It
  • Simple and safe to use
  • Ideal for kids
  • Makes 1.5 quarts in 40mins
  • Fluffy, smooth soft ice cream
  • Freeze bowl before use
Capacity
1.5 quarts
Freezing Time
40 mins
Dimensions
9.1 x 8 x 8 inches
Our Verdict

We like the iSiLER Maker because it encourages children to get into the kitchen and learn how to make a dessert or two for their family and friends.

Editor Rating

Ice Cream Makers Buying Guide

It sounds so simple in theory – when you feel like having some ice cream, rather than going out to the shops and forking out a huge amount for what is essentially frozen flavored milk, make it yourself! Ice cream makers used to be reserved for those who worked in restaurants or in ice cream factories. Nowadays, however, you can find an ice cream or frozen yogurt maker in nearly every home. We just cannot get enough of the sweet, smooth and delicious frozen dessert.

Nothing is ever completely simple, however. One looks at the range of different ice cream makers on the market will make it clear that there is a vast array of different makers specializing in different areas, all having varied features with differing price points. So what is the difference, and what are the main considerations when purchasing an ice cream maker for your own home?

Check is pre-freezing is required: Many ice cream makers do not actually act as a freezer – so they require a special bowl to be pre-frozen prior to the actual start of the process. This means that unless you are prepared, you cannot decide to make ice cream on a whim – you need to start at least one day prior to actually eating the finished product. For most families, this won’t be a problem. You can just leave the bowl in the freezer all the time and take it out when you decide to make some ice cream.

But for those with limited freezer space or who just do not like the idea of having the pre-freeze process, there are makers with compressors or a built in freezer that will do the freezing as part of the process, like how you see on the cooking shows. Make sure you read the product descriptions and make inquiries to understand how it works before you buy to avoid future disappointment.

Capacity: It is difficult to look at an ice cream maker and have a definite idea of just how much ice cream it will make at one time. The exterior does not show the size of the bowl or take into account the motor and various paddles. The only way to know exactly how much ice-cream you will get out of a single batch is to check the specifications. Generally, they range anywhere between 1.5 and 6 quarts. Smaller capacity ones have the benefit of being quicker and easier to store.

However, if you need to feed a group of people or a family, you will require at least a 4-quart maker. Price is also generally not a great indicator of capacity – some of the more expensive ice cream makers can be smaller and vice versa. Think about your needs, compare the size of an average tub you normally purchase from the shops and read the specifications before you buy.

Ice cream, Soft Serve, Frozen Yogurt, Gelato or Sorbet?

If you are unsure on whether you and your family would prefer traditional ice cream, smooth soft serve, healthy frozen yogurt, dairy free gelato or refreshing sorbet, then you will be happy to know that most of the ice cream makers will make all of the above. Some may specialize in soft serve or frozen yogurt but chances are that there will be a way to make any different type. This is because the process is generally the same, it is just the ingredients that differ.

So no matter what style of frozen dessert you like, chances are that any of the featured ice cream makers will be able to make it. The best bet is to read the recipe book if possible, which will give you some great ideas for flavors and styles of ice cream that you may not have considered. Some of the ice cream makers that we have reviewed also come with lots of recipes for many fresh and delicious flavors.

Is it Possible to have more than a Single Flavor at a Time?

Unfortunately, this is one limitation of the at-home ice cream maker. Generally, they only have the one churner so can only make one batch in a single flavor at any one time. And because most common ice cream makers require the mixing bowl to be completely frozen prior to churning, you will need to wait around a day in-between making different flavors or batches. The best way to overcome this limitation is to purchase a compressor style maker (such as the  Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker).

The compressor means that you do not need to freeze the bowl, so you can effectively make batch after batch of whatever flavor you want one after the other. Simple scoop out the ice cream when it is finished, clean the bowl and start the process again immediately. Alternatively, you can purchase additional bowls so you can keep them pre-frozen and make one batch at a time. Make sure you check the particular maker’s specifications so you know if additional bowls are needed.

What Ice Cream Flavors can the Ice Cream Makers Make?

The only limit to what flavor of ice cream you can make is your imagination! Any flavor combination is possible – if you have the ingredients and they fit in the maker (within reason of course), then you will be able to make it. Most of the ice cream makers will come with recipe books filled with ideas, and a quick look on the internet will unearth many other flavor combinations you may not have even considered.

One great thing about home-made ice cream is that you can control or change ingredients to meet your specific needs –  for example, if you are sensitive to milk and find it hard to find dairy-free ice creams in your preferred flavor, then you can purchase your favorite soy or rice milk and adjust the recipe.

And if your favorite fruit is lychees and you have been looking for a lychee flavored sorbet, then stop looking as you will now be able to make it yourself at home! Use your imagination, and after some trial and error, you will build yourself a real catalog of great ice cream and frozen yogurt flavors that the whole family will love and look forward to.

Is an at-home Ice Cream Maker Good Value for Money?

Some of the higher end ice cream makers on the market can be rather pricey – ranging anywhere between $30 and $300. So you may be questioning whether it really is worth the extra expense when ice cream from the grocery store really is not that expensive and is delicious in its own way. The main reason that people will want to make ice cream at home is more the fact that it is a fun process that the kids can help with, and the fact that the ingredients can be controlled so is perfect for people with food allergies and sensitivities. You can simply google a flavor online and create it right there!

How expensive a batch of ice cream costs to make completely depends on the ingredients used. If you buy premium fruit at full price and only use organic milk, then yes It will be more expensive than purchasing shop bought ice cream (although will likely taste better and be better for your health). Buying ingredients in bulk or when on a special offer is the best way to lower the cost of making the ice cream at home.

If you stop buying the premium ice cream from the shops, then the maker will pay for itself after only a few months. Plus you will now have batches of ice cream to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings without significant expenses every now and then. Another great benefit from home-made ice cream is the fact that you can completely control the amount of sugar, salt, and other additives – if you don’t like a particular ingredient, then simply do not add it to the recipe!

Most good ice cream makers will come with ice cream recipe books with lots of ideas outside of the traditional ice cream flavors. So whether home-made ice cream is better than store bought is really a matter of perspective. The sheer popularity of these ice cream makers seems to validate that they are doing something right.